Leah
Written on Nov 1, 2013
I wasn’t entirely taken with The Good Boy, I will quite happily admit that I think it was a bit too clever for my liking. I followed the story pretty well when it was just Pete or Joel and Butchie we were following but when different police officers/gang members etc all got involved, I couldn’t seem to make head nor tail of what was going on. I just didn’t get how the story came about, how the story ended, I had no idea what was going on in those last few pages and I just finished it feeling totally confused.
There were good bits, I loved the way Schwegel presented Butchie and Joel’s relationship, that was really lovely and I will always turn to mush when it comes to a dog and its owners relationship, and I did enjoy reading of Pete’s journey to try and find his son, but the rest of it? I couldn’t keep up. I especially felt that McKenna and Sarah, Joel’s sister and mother, were wasted and didn’t seem to be part of the novel at all, except for a little bit, I would have expected a mother to be a bit more concerned than she was, but since she was numbed by alcohol, it’s not entirely surprising.
This book was just hard going for me. Sometimes I do like a grittier novel, but I like a grittier novel that I can keep up with and sadly I couldn’t keep up with The Good Boy. It was a difficult one, although there is one scene in particular that will stay with me forever involving a cat called Felix Catus and that I wish I’d never had to read. That was really bad, really harrowing and I know stuff like that happens in real life, but it’s stuff I’d rather not see/read/hear because it upsets me and I just do not understand how people can act that way towards animals. This will be much-loved I’m sure, and one critics will fall all over, but I found it was just too much for me to cope with and I finished it feeling more confused than when I’d started it.